Visual Library API - Architecture Review Opinion

Issue: 95110
Submitter: David Kaspar
Date: March 8th, 2007
Reviewers: Joelle Lam, Anton Epple, Nathan Fiedler, Milos Kleint, Jaroslav Tulach (not voting)




The purpose of this API is to create a library for easier development of visual applications based on the NetBeans Platform. Long-term goal is to provide tools to unify the UI appearance and behaviour of those applications.


Accepted with TCRs


Renaming of non-standard names

Some names of methods/classes are non-standard e.g. FillLayout.
TCR: Change those names to standard ones e.g. OverlayLayout.
This will introduce an backward-incompatible change against the release551 branch.

Missing support for ActionMap

ActionMap class is a standard and should be integrated into the library.
TCR: Create an ActionFactory.createActionMapAction method which creates a wrapper widget-action that handles keyPressed and popup-menu creation.

Move deprecated classes from the public API

The library contains a few deprecated classes and methods.
TCR: Since there would be incompatible-change already, move these deprecated (to-be-changed) classes to non-public API packages. Users would be able to access them suing the implementation dependency.

VMD package

The library contains a VMD package. It is a particular implementation of a visualization.
Answer: do NOT move it to a separate module, do NOT rename it
TCR: Improve javadoc

Public, non-final classes/methods

The library contains a lot of non-public or final elements.
Answer: Because of API maintaince, it should stay like it is right now.
An API change request could be sent to the mailing list or entered as an issue with API_REVIEW or API_REVIEW_FAST keywords.
The API change process will follow standard or fast-tract review steps. For details, see Architecture Review Steps.

Minority Opinion



Appendix A: Technical Changes Required

97562 - Renaming of non-standard names
97563 - Missing support for ActionMap
97564 - Move deprecated classes from the public API
(not entered into IZ) - Improve VMD package javadoc

Appendix B: Technical Changes Advised


Appendix C: Reference Material


Project Features

About this Project

openide was started in November 2009, is owned by Antonin Nebuzelsky, and has 53 members.
By use of this website, you agree to the NetBeans Policies and Terms of Use (revision 20160708.bf2ac18). © 2014, Oracle Corporation and/or its affiliates. Sponsored by Oracle logo
Please Confirm